Randall Kaplan, co-founder of Akamai Technologies and founder of JUMP Investors

How to Ask for Feedback You Can Actually Use

October 29, 2026

By Randall Kaplan

“You did a good job” can be pleasant to hear and almost impossible to use. We don’t know which part worked, which part nearly failed, or what we should repeat next time.

Sometimes we receive vague feedback because we asked a vague question. “How did I do?” requires the other person to decide what to evaluate and how candid to be. A more focused question makes it easier to give us something useful.

The quality of feedback also depends on what happens after we receive it. People learn quickly whether we want information or reassurance. Our response can determine how honest the next conversation becomes.

A Question About a Moment

After a presentation, we could ask, “Was it good?” Or we could ask, “At what point was it clear what decision I needed from the group?”

The second question gives the other person a specific moment to recall. If they cannot identify one, we’ve learned something important about the structure of the presentation.

For a manager, the question might involve a difficult conversation: “Did I explain the expectation clearly before discussing what went wrong?” For a candidate, it might involve an interview answer: “Which part helped you understand my contribution?”

We’re choosing a question that connects to the skill we want to improve. That focus makes the answer easier to apply and less likely to become a general judgment about our ability.

The Person With a Useful View

Different people can see different parts of our performance. A colleague in the meeting can describe how the discussion landed. Someone reviewing the materials afterward can identify what was unclear without the spoken explanation.

We should consider which perspective we need. A trusted friend may be supportive but unfamiliar with the responsibility we’re trying to perform. A teammate may understand the work but hesitate to challenge someone with more authority.

That does not make either perspective worthless. It means we should understand the limits of the information and make candor easier where we can.

For example, we can ask for one specific improvement instead of a full evaluation. We can also explain what we’re practicing so the person knows which details to notice.

The Response That Keeps the Door Open

When the feedback arrives, our first job is to understand it. We may need an example or a description of the moment that created the impression.

If someone says our answer sounded defensive, we can ask which wording gave that impression. Explaining immediately that we did not intend to be defensive may be true, but it does little to clarify what they experienced.

We can acknowledge the information without agreeing with every interpretation. “That helps me understand how it landed” leaves room to reflect. It also communicates that the person’s effort was worthwhile.

The real test comes later. If we ask for candor and then punish the person socially or professionally for providing it, we’ve made future feedback less likely to be honest.

The Change Small Enough to Practice

Feedback becomes useful when it changes preparation or behavior. A broad commitment to communicate better may not survive the next busy day.

Suppose the observation is that we bury the decision beneath too much background. We can practice opening with the decision needed, then providing the evidence that supports it. A colleague can listen to the revised opening and tell us whether the purpose is clear.

Extreme Preparation® includes that return to practice. We’re using an observation to improve the next performance before the stakes are real.

A coach can help distinguish a useful adjustment from an overreaction. One person’s preference does not always justify rebuilding our entire approach. We need to understand the context and look for patterns without dismissing an uncomfortable observation simply because it is new.

The Follow Through People Remember

After we’ve tried the change, we can return to the person who helped us. A short explanation of what we adjusted shows that their feedback had a purpose.

We might say, “I moved the decision to the opening this time. Was the request easier to follow?” That closes the loop and gives us a second observation to compare.

Feedback does not need to become a constant referendum on our worth. It can be a practical exchange about a skill, a decision, or a moment we want to handle better.

When we make the question specific and the response receptive, we give other people a better chance to help us. Then our responsibility is to do something thoughtful with what they noticed.

About Randall Kaplan

Randall Kaplan is a serial entrepreneur, investor, and executive coach. He’s a co-founder of Akamai Technologies and the founder and CEO of JUMP Investors, which has invested in more than 100 early-to-late-stage companies, including Google, Seagate, and Lyft. For 25 years, he’s coached hundreds of entrepreneurs, business owners, and executives. He created Extreme Preparation® to help people pursue their boldest ambitions, overcome the obstacles standing in their way, and change the course of their careers, businesses, and lives.

He also interviews some of the world’s most successful people, including Mark Cuban, Tony Robbins, Mike Tyson, David Solomon, and David Rubenstein, on his podcast In Search of Excellence, which has reached as high as #3 in Entrepreneurship and #10 in Business on Apple Podcasts.

Learn more about executive coaching with Randall.