Randall Kaplan, co-founder of Akamai Technologies and founder of JUMP Investors

How to Get Your First Customers Through Better Conversations

November 7, 2026

By Randall Kaplan

A new business can look convincing from behind a laptop. The website is polished, the presentation is ready, and the offer makes sense to everyone who has helped us build it. Then we have to ask someone outside that circle to buy.

That conversation exposes questions that planning alone cannot settle. Does the problem matter enough? Is this the person who can decide? What would make changing from the current approach worthwhile?

Getting our first customers requires learning those answers while making a clear offer. We need enough preparation to be relevant and enough openness to discover that the market sees the problem differently.

A Customer We Can Describe Precisely

“Small businesses” is a large audience for a first sales effort. A more useful starting point identifies a type of person with a recognizable situation.

For example, a founder offering help with customer onboarding might begin with service businesses whose owners still handle every new account personally. That description gives the founder a reason to believe the problem could exist and a way to investigate it.

The initial group should be narrow enough that the conversations teach us something comparable. If every prospect has a different problem, role, and buying process, it becomes harder to understand why anyone responds.

We can expand later. At the beginning, clarity helps us learn faster and speak more specifically.

The Current Workaround Tells a Story

Before presenting the solution, we should understand how the person handles the problem today. A workaround may be inconvenient but familiar, inexpensive, and good enough for their current needs.

We can ask about a recent example. How did the last new customer get started? Where did the owner become involved? What happened when information was missing?

Those details are more useful than asking whether the person likes our idea. Many people will be encouraging. Fewer will change their behavior or spend money to use what we’ve built.

Extreme Preparation® includes researching the customer’s situation while remaining willing to revise our assumptions. We’re preparing to understand a decision, not simply preparing a persuasive speech.

An Offer Small Enough to Evaluate

Our first offer should make clear what the customer receives, what they need to contribute, and how both sides will judge the work. Vague promises of transformation can hide a basic misunderstanding about the service.

For the onboarding example, the offer might involve mapping one existing process and testing a revised handoff for a defined type of customer. The scope should be realistic for the business to deliver.

If the engagement is paid, the price and terms should be clear. If it is a limited pilot, we should explain what happens when it ends. We should not imply that a free trial demonstrates willingness to pay.

A customer can evaluate a concrete proposal more easily than an unlimited promise. So can we.

Outreach With a Reason to Respond

A useful outreach message explains why we’re contacting this person, which problem we may be able to address, and the small next step we’re proposing. It should reflect something relevant about their business without pretending we know its internal difficulties.

We might say that our work focuses on owner-led onboarding and ask whether that remains part of their role. That leaves room for them to tell us our assumption is wrong.

When appropriate, a short follow-up can add a useful clarification. Repeated messages that ignore silence or a clear refusal can damage the relationship before one begins.

A coach or advisor can review our message and role-play the first conversation. The useful question is whether a stranger can understand the offer and why it might matter to them.

What a No Can Teach Us

After each conversation, we can record the reason the opportunity advanced or stopped. The issue may be timing, authority, trust, price, or a problem that simply does not matter enough.

Those explanations should remain provisional unless the prospect actually gave them. Silence is not a detailed market analysis, and we should not treat our guess as one.

Patterns across comparable conversations can guide the next experiment. We may need a different customer group, clearer scope, or stronger evidence that we can deliver.

Our first customers do more than create revenue. They help us understand the work people value enough to choose. When we approach those conversations with preparation and attention, we give ourselves a better chance to build a business around something customers actually need.

About Randall Kaplan

Randall Kaplan is a serial entrepreneur, investor, and executive coach. He’s a co-founder of Akamai Technologies and the founder and CEO of JUMP Investors, which has invested in more than 100 early-to-late-stage companies, including Google, Seagate, and Lyft. For 25 years, he’s coached hundreds of entrepreneurs, business owners, and executives. He created Extreme Preparation® to help people pursue their boldest ambitions, overcome the obstacles standing in their way, and change the course of their careers, businesses, and lives.

He also interviews some of the world’s most successful people, including Mark Cuban, Tony Robbins, Mike Tyson, David Solomon, and David Rubenstein, on his podcast In Search of Excellence, which has reached as high as #3 in Entrepreneurship and #10 in Business on Apple Podcasts.

Learn more about executive coaching with Randall.