
By Randall Kaplan
An investor asks a simple question: “Why do customers need this now?” The founder clicks back three slides, describes the product again, and ends with a statement about the size of the opportunity.
The question is still unanswered. A polished deck can organize a business case, but it cannot supply the understanding behind it. That has to come from us.
As founders, we should be able to explain the business when the slides are unavailable, the order changes, or the listener becomes interested in a different issue. A pitch is a conversation about a decision. The materials should help that conversation move forward.
Our opening should make it possible to understand who the customer is, which problem we address, and what we provide. If the listener cannot explain those basics back to us, the rest of the pitch rests on an unstable foundation.
We can test the explanation with someone unfamiliar with the business. Their confusion is useful information. It may reveal a term that needs translating or a business model we’ve not yet made clear enough ourselves.
For example, “We automate operations” leaves many possibilities open. Describing which task a particular customer currently handles manually gives the listener somewhere to begin.
We can add complexity once the basic picture is clear. An impressive vocabulary should not become the price of understanding our company.
Every central claim should connect to evidence we can explain. If customers want the product, what have they done that supports that conclusion? If the process saves time, how was that observed?
We need to distinguish customer conversations, trial use, signed commitments, and payments. Each tells us something different. Blurring them can make a slide appear stronger while making the conversation less credible.
The same care applies to projections. We should know which assumptions drive the result and what would change if one of them proved wrong. A projection is a model of possibilities, not a report of something that already happened.
We’re asking the listener to evaluate our judgment. The way we qualify evidence is part of that judgment.
A list of previous employers may establish experience without explaining why this team is suited to this problem. We need to connect the background to the work ahead.
Perhaps someone has served the target customer directly. Perhaps a team member understands the difficult operational task at the center of the product. Those connections should be specific and accurate.
We should also acknowledge capabilities we still need. A hiring plan becomes more credible when we can explain the responsibility, why it matters now, and what remains unresolved until it is filled.
There is no advantage in pretending the team is complete if the next stage requires skills nobody currently owns. A thoughtful account of the gap can show that we understand the challenge.
Extreme Preparation® includes practicing the pitch under conditions that interrupt our preferred flow. A coach or advisor can ask a difficult question before the slide that usually introduces it.
We can then practice answering the question directly and returning to the conversation without restarting the entire presentation. If we need to show supporting material, we should be able to find it quickly.
One useful exercise is to explain the business with no slides at all. Another is to deliver a much shorter version that preserves the essential case. Both reveal whether the narrative depends on the screen to make sense.
Rehearsal should expose the weak point while there is still time to improve it. A smooth run-through that nobody challenges can miss that purpose.
At the end, we should know what we’re asking the listener to do next. Is this an initial discussion about fit, a request to review further material, or a conversation about a specific funding need?
The request should match the stage of the relationship and the information exchanged. We can confirm which questions remain open and what we’ve agreed to provide.
A strong pitch leaves the listener able to explain the business and the reason to continue. The slides may help them remember it, but our understanding gives the materials their value. When we can discuss the opportunity clearly under questioning, we demonstrate something a presentation alone cannot: we’re prepared to think about the business in the room.
Randall Kaplan is a serial entrepreneur, investor, and executive coach. He’s a co-founder of Akamai Technologies and the founder and CEO of JUMP Investors, which has invested in more than 100 early-to-late-stage companies, including Google, Seagate, and Lyft. For 25 years, he’s coached hundreds of entrepreneurs, business owners, and executives. He created Extreme Preparation® to help people pursue their boldest ambitions, overcome the obstacles standing in their way, and change the course of their careers, businesses, and lives.
He also interviews some of the world’s most successful people, including Mark Cuban, Tony Robbins, Mike Tyson, David Solomon, and David Rubenstein, on his podcast In Search of Excellence, which has reached as high as #3 in Entrepreneurship and #10 in Business on Apple Podcasts.