
By Randall Kaplan
An idea can become part of our identity surprisingly quickly. We tell friends about it, imagine the company it could become, and start explaining why it will work. Soon, a question about the idea can feel like a question about us.
That makes early testing important. We want to learn about the business while it is still possible to change the approach without defending months of work or a large commitment.
A useful test does more than produce encouragement. It helps us decide whether an assumption is strong enough to build on. The preparation begins with naming the assumption we most need to understand.
Every business idea contains several beliefs. We believe a problem exists, that a particular customer cares about it, that our approach could help, and that the customer would choose it over alternatives.
Some beliefs matter more than others at the beginning. A beautiful design cannot rescue an offer for a problem nobody considers important. A large audience is less useful if the people affected cannot approve a purchase.
We can identify the uncertainty that would most change our next decision. For a proposed service, that might be whether buyers already spend meaningful time or resources solving the problem.
The test should address that question directly. Otherwise, we may collect interesting information while avoiding the assumption that makes us uncomfortable.
People are often generous when asked about a new idea. They may say they would use it because they want to encourage us or because imagining a purchase is easier than making one.
We can learn more by asking about a recent experience. When did the problem last occur? What did they do? Who became involved? What did the current solution fail to accomplish?
For example, a proposed scheduling service might sound appealing to almost anyone. A recent account of missed appointments, manual coordination, and a decision to pay for help tells us much more.
We should avoid turning every answer into a sales argument. If we interrupt the person to explain why our idea solves everything, we lose the opportunity to understand their actual experience.
Once the problem is clearer, we can decide what demonstration would help someone evaluate the offer. We may not need a complete product to learn whether the proposed result matters.
A service could be demonstrated through a limited engagement. A workflow could be illustrated with a sample using appropriate, nonconfidential information. A prototype could show one important action rather than every feature we imagine.
We should be clear about what exists and what is only proposed. A test loses value if people commit based on capabilities we cannot deliver.
Extreme Preparation® means choosing the details that improve the next decision. At this stage, that may mean preparing one honest demonstration instead of building an elaborate version of an untested assumption.
Before running the test, we should decide what result would make us continue, change the approach, or pause. That keeps us from redefining success after every response.
The evidence should fit the question. If we’re testing whether the problem matters, detailed accounts of repeated difficulty are useful. If we’re testing willingness to pay, compliments and newsletter signups answer a different question.
Small tests have limits. A few interested people do not establish the size of a market, and a poor first message does not prove there is no demand. We need to understand what the test can reasonably tell us.
A coach or advisor can challenge our interpretation, particularly when we’re excited enough to see every signal as confirmation.
The result should change something. We may narrow the audience, revise the offer, investigate a different problem, or proceed with a more demanding test.
We can write down the decision and the evidence behind it. That record helps us remember what we actually learned instead of gradually converting a hopeful interpretation into a fact.
Testing an idea does not remove uncertainty from entrepreneurship. It gives us a way to confront uncertainty while our choices remain flexible. We’re investing effort in learning what deserves a larger commitment.
Our ambition can stay large while the next test stays focused. The idea becomes stronger when it survives contact with the people who would need it. And when it changes because of what they tell us, that is evidence that we’re listening closely enough to build something useful.
Randall Kaplan is a serial entrepreneur, investor, and executive coach. He’s a co-founder of Akamai Technologies and the founder and CEO of JUMP Investors, which has invested in more than 100 early-to-late-stage companies, including Google, Seagate, and Lyft. For 25 years, he’s coached hundreds of entrepreneurs, business owners, and executives. He created Extreme Preparation® to help people pursue their boldest ambitions, overcome the obstacles standing in their way, and change the course of their careers, businesses, and lives.
He also interviews some of the world’s most successful people, including Mark Cuban, Tony Robbins, Mike Tyson, David Solomon, and David Rubenstein, on his podcast In Search of Excellence, which has reached as high as #3 in Entrepreneurship and #10 in Business on Apple Podcasts.